Top Insurance Agencies in New York City

Discover which insurance agencies in New York City are most recommended by AI platforms. Based on real answers — no sponsored placements.

Free. No credit card required.

AI Platforms
ChatGPTClaudePerplexityGemini
Top Pick

State Farm

Mentioned by 3 out of 4 platforms

Key Stats

4

Platforms analyzed

10

Businesses listed

This page answers: "Which insurance agencies are most recommended in New York City? List the top ones (as many as you can) with their name and locations" We analyzed how often insurance agencies in New York City are mentioned across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini. Each platform was queried independently using the same prompt. Rankings reflect real visibility across AI platforms, not paid placements or directories.

Which insurance agencies are most recommended in New York City? List the top ones (as many as you can) with their name and locations

4

Platforms analyzed

10

Businesses listed

"Which insurance agencies are most recommended in New York City?"

Query used

7 of 10 listed businesses were mentioned by 2 or more AI platforms.

2 businesses share the highest mention count (3 of 4 platforms) for this query.

🏆 Top 3

1

State Farm

Multiple locations throughout NYC boroughs

Mentioned by 3 out of 4 platforms analyzed

2

GEICO

Multiple locations in NYC including Queens, Brooklyn, and Manhattan

Mentioned by 3 out of 4 platforms analyzed

3

Travelers

Headquartered in New York City

Mentioned by 2 out of 4 platforms analyzed

Full Ranking

4

Allstate

Multiple locations across NYC boroughs

Mentioned by 2 out of 4 platforms analyzed

5

Farmers Insurance

Multiple locations throughout New York City

Mentioned by 2 out of 4 platforms analyzed

6

Progressive

Multiple NYC area locations

Mentioned by 2 out of 4 platforms analyzed

7

Liberty Mutual

Several NYC locations including Manhattan

Mentioned by 2 out of 4 platforms analyzed

8

Marsh & McLennan Agency (MMA)

Multiple offices in Manhattan including Midtown and Financial District

Mentioned by 1 out of 4 platforms analyzed

9

State Farm Insurance

Multiple locations across NYC including Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens

Mentioned by 1 out of 4 platforms analyzed

10

Allstate Insurance

Offices in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and other boroughs

Mentioned by 1 out of 4 platforms analyzed

Top Insurance Agencies in Other Cities

Other Top Businesses in New York City

Frequently Asked Questions

How are these insurance agencies ranked?

Rankings are based on how often each insurance agencie appears in AI-generated responses across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini. The more platforms that mention a business, the higher it ranks. This is not an editorial ranking — it reflects real AI output.

Why do some businesses have the same mention count?

Because multiple businesses can appear on the same number of platforms. When that happens, we use tie-breakers such as the position in each platform's list and how often the business appears in top-3 positions.

Are any of these placements sponsored or paid?

No. There are no sponsored placements anywhere on this page. Rankings are determined entirely by the output of the AI platforms we query.

Why is my business not listed for insurance agencies in New York City?

Only businesses that the AI platforms named in their responses appear here. If a business was not mentioned by ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, or Gemini for this specific query, it will not show up — even if it is well-known locally.

Are the AI platforms queried independently?

Yes. Each platform is queried on its own with the same prompt. We do not pass results from one platform into another, and we do not combine outputs before analysis.

Does this page recommend or endorse any of these insurance agencies?

No. The page reports which businesses AI platforms mention in response to a specific question. It does not constitute an endorsement, verification, or recommendation by us.

How AI systems evaluate this industry

AI platforms weigh the following signals when deciding which businesses to surface for this category:

  • industry authority
  • regulatory signals
  • review quality
  • citation sources
  • geographic relevance
  • recommendation overlap

Related AI concepts

Explore the concepts and signals that influence how AI systems rank, compare, and recommend organizations in this industry.

See how Findable measures this

Findable analyzes these signals across multiple AI systems to understand how organizations are cited, recommended, and compared.

Learn more about AI visibility

Learn more about how AI search, recommendations, and citations work.

Explore rankings by city and industry

About this ranking

Collected from AI answers. No sponsored placements — rankings are determined entirely by AI platform output. This is not a directory; it is a transparency tool showing which businesses AI recommends.

How rankings work

We compare recommendations across major AI platforms. Each platform counts once per business. Rankings reflect total cross-platform mentions.

This ranking is a static snapshot based on mention counts, not the AI Visibility Score (a separate Findable metric for an individual brand's AI presence). There is no automatic or scheduled refresh — rankings reflect the date shown above.

Read the full Top Brands methodology

These rankings are informed by:

  • 15,780 Competitors discovered
  • 96,421 Competitor observations
  • 7.49 Average competitors per brand

Want to see if your business appears in AI results?

Check how AI platforms like ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Gemini describe your business.

Check your AI visibility

Free. No credit card required.

Findable

© 2025 Findable. All rights reserved.